You Are Both
River and Stone
Two ways of being one thing
Physics — what the concept means
EstablishedSend light at a barrier with two openings and it produces an interference pattern, the signature of a wave passing through both. Place a detector that determines which opening each photon went through and the interference disappears. You get two bands, the signature of particles.
Neither description is the whole truth. Which behaviour appears depends on what the system is made to interact with.
One thing is worth stating early, because the rest of this folio depends on it. In physics, measurement means interaction with a detector or an environment. It does not mean a conscious observer. Nothing in the mathematics requires a mind. A photographic plate in an empty room does it perfectly well.
Biology — what the research establishes
EstablishedThe lymphatic system has no central pump. Lymph is moved against a pressure gradient by two mechanisms working together: the intrinsic rhythmic contraction of lymphangions, the short valved segments of the collecting vessels, and extrinsic compression from skeletal muscle, breathing, arterial pulsation and gut movement.
Which mechanism dominates depends on where you are in the body and what that part of the body is doing. Extrinsic pumping leads in the thorax, skeletal muscle and gut wall. Intrinsic contraction carries most other lymphatic beds.
This means movement and breath are not adjacent to lymphatic flow. They are part of the pump.
Correspondence — what appears between them
CorrespondenceTwo systems, both of which refuse a single description. Light is not sometimes a wave and sometimes a particle in the way a coin is sometimes heads. The description that appears depends on the conditions of the encounter. Lymph is not sometimes fluid and sometimes cargo. The mechanism that carries it depends on what the surrounding body is doing.
The resemblance is structural. It is not a shared mechanism, and no part of lymphatic function is quantum mechanical in any established sense.
PropositionThe wave is not destroyed by becoming the particle. It is completed by it.
Embodied observationA body kept permanently braced is a body whose extrinsic pump has stopped offering. Stillness is not the opposite of circulation. In this system it is one of its engines.
Breath and movement are established components of lymphatic transport, not adjuncts to it. The proposition is what to make of that: that the state we call rest is a working mode of the body rather than an interruption of one, and that a life which never enters it has switched off half a pump.
Sources and further reading
Lymphatic pumping: mechanics, mechanisms and malfunction
Scallan, Zawieja, Castorena-Gonzalez & Davis · The Journal of Physiology · 2016 · Established
Supports: no central pump; lymph moved by intrinsic lymphangion contraction plus extrinsic forces. doi:10.1113/JP272088
Lymphatic vessels and their surroundings: how local physical factors affect lymph flow
Solari, Marcozzi, Negrini & Moriondo · Biology · 2020 · Established
Supports: absence of a central pump; respiration and tissue movement as extrinsic pumping. PMC7763507
The uncertainty principle
Hilgevoord & Uffink · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · revised edition · Established
Supports: measurement in quantum mechanics as interaction rather than conscious observation. plato.stanford.edu
I